Thursday, February 23, 2006

American Idol is back


After weeks of screwin' around, Idol is finally back. We watch it with more interest than is probably healthy in our house. Before they start dropping people, Jenn and I have put together our top 12. Here's mine: (I'll post Jenn's later.)

Guys:
1. Taylor Hicks
2. Ace Young
3. Chris Doughtry
4. Elliott Yamin
5. Will Makar
6. Patrick Hall

Girls:
1. Katherine McPhee
2. Lisa Tucker
3. Paris Bennett
4. Mandisa
5. Ayla Brown
6. Heather Cox

Some comments:

The 5 and 6 slots for the guys were tough because 1-4 were vastly superior to the rest. I wouldn't be surprised if Gedeon and Sway make it. Unless the people calling in are completely nuts--admittedly a possibility--there's no way Bucky, Bobby, David, or Kevin should make it.

As to the girls, Heather (see above) makes the cut not because she's the best singer among the rest but because she is smokin'. I would say that, of the rest, Melissa and Kinnik are the best. Brenna is really annoying--though perhaps that will appeal to certain deranged segments of the population. And there's just no way, absent much improvement, that Becky, Stevie, and (as cute as she is) Kellie Pickler will make it.

More on this very important topic later.

Posted by jwb at 11:40 AM   

1 Comments:

Blogger ~A4O~ said:

hahaha.kool post and I agree with your picks. Saw in your profile you like art and have a bit on my blog to go with some poetry I've written. Check it out if you want. Later...
at 12:13 PM     

Post a Comment
« home